Slinging the Sludge Landfill Expansion

Slinging the Sludge – The Truth About the Proposed Landfill Expansion in Gardner MA

With any public issue, it is important that the facts be published with accuracy. The truth: Public officials in Gardner have shown great concern about the environment throughout all steps of considering the expansion of the Landfill. The truth: A third party report was commissioned. The truth: Afterwards, a decision was made to proceed and the public comment period with the state went through the end of January. The truth: Dane Arnold has commented on the issue – to the Public Service Committee to which he often reports on his Department. The truth: Mayor Nicholson has acknowledged that this is just a stop gap measure in need of a longer term solution. The truth: The Conservation Commission has met often on the issue and discussed it at length.

We do something other publications don’t do: We publish the actual AUDIO of meetings, so you can draw your own conclusions. The evidence below will show the issue has been carefully considered.

Starting in May 2022, We reported on the City moving forward with the Landfill Expansion, the discussions of the Conservation Commission, the discussions before the Public Service Committee, and various interviews with Gardner Mayor Michael Nicholson. Our evidence is the AUDIO of the meetings and interviews themselves, demonstrating clearly that environmental concerns were clearly identified and studied, alternatives were explored, financial considerations were calculated, and the need for a longer term solution was acknowledged.

Chronology of Our Reporting on Issue

May 2022: Sewage Sludge Decisions in Gardner MA
July 2022: Moving Forward on Landfill Expansion
August 2022: Chairman of Conservation Commission stated he would “not be bullied, harassed, called, bamboozled, dumped on” stating we’re going to do the right thing.” Topic of Sludge has complete AUDIO of meeting.
August 23, 2022: Sludge Again – Once again, issue at Conservation Commission. Article has complete AUDIO of meeting.
August 2022: We interviewed Gardner Mayor Nicholson in our Citizen Concerns Interview and he stated, “I think there’s just some misinformation that’s out there, not understanding the full project. …Like the fact that we’re even at this point means that everything’s had to be vetted as thoroughly as possible by the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, the EPA. This is something that, we have to be remembering our fiduciary responsibility that we have for our rate payers. Article has complete AUDIO of the Mayor’s comments.
September 2022: Conservation Commission took up the matter again on 9-26-22, approving $700 for a 3rd party opinion. Article has complete AUDIO of meeting.
October 2022: DPW Director Dane Arnold spoke at a meeting of the Public Service Committee on 10-13-22, saying, “The Sludge Landfill report by a 3rd party should be in soon and then next steps can be taken. Article has complete AUDIO of meeting.
November 2022: The Conservation Commission met on 11-14-22 regarding Tighe and Bond findings: Article has complete AUDIO of meeting.
11-21-22: We interviewed Gardner Mayor Michael Nicholson and he stated, “So those all go to the state now for a full review, to make sure that there’s no contaminants that could possibly leak out, that the liner is set to be, you know, sturdy and sustainable, to make sure that everything there , is above board , there’s probably at least six to eight months in that process, to make sure that all the eyes are dotted and the t’s crossed” Interview has complete AUDIO.
December 2022: The Public Service Committee discussed the expansion of the Sludge Landfill on 12-2-22. Article has complete AUDIO of meeting.
January 2023: Mayor Nicholson spoke about the issue on WGAW’s Hotline Radio stating that the project was under MEPA review. And the Mayor stated, “We only have about 3 to 5 years to figure out something for this, otherwise we’re really gonna be up the creek in terms of potentially tripling our rate for our sewer rates in order to truck the sewage someplace else or some other type of really expensive alternative here.”
February 2023: Lessons About History Interview: Mayor Nicholson stated, “We need to figure out the process right now so that we can have an immediate plan, but also plan ahead in the future, so that once that’s done, we’re not in the same spot we are again in the next fifteen to twenty years, but we have something already started, so once we can get through this very painful process, we already have something planned to go. Interview has complete AUDIO.

We can’t find any important piece missing in this puzzle. A final decision on the matter should be known in the coming months.