Krista Sturgeon to Kimberly Blake: “Please Just Stop, Just Stop, I Thought you Were Running on a Fair and Nice Campaign” Claims Blake Lied to FBI
Gardner Magazine interviewed Krista Sturgeon who states she at one point was a friend and supporter of Kimberly Blake. Sturgeon feels differently now. After a number of Facebook message exchanges, Publisher Werner Poegel agreed to meet Sturgeon at a public place for an interview with the understanding that he would record everything and present it in its entirety for the public to hear. Interview was recorded Friday May 23, 2025 at the Walmart Subway in Gardner. Bottom line: Krista Sturgeon had a lot to say about Kimberly Blake. According to Sturgeon, many of Blake’s statements have been made with no factual basis at all. CLICK PLAY.
Background: Krista Sturgeon is a taxpayer who owns a home in Gardner and has lived in Gardner for about a decade. She lives with a partner of 10 years. Due to Parkinson’s Disease and lupus, Sturgeon has a service dog named Daniel Boone who came with her to the interview. He was adorable and well-behaved..
Some statements from the interview:
Krista Sturgeon refers to a time recently when she messaged Blake about salacious posts containing false allegations against Mayor Nicholson “If you’re going to do this, take that down..”
According to Sturgeon, Kimberly Blake made a false report to the FBI about a video which Sturgeon does not believe actually exists. Publisher Poegel asked “Well, you messaged me, and you were very specific, that you thought that Kimberly Blake had lied to the FBI. Is that correct? “Sturgeon stated: “That is correct. I’ve never seen the video.”
After their friendship soured Sturgeon says that at one point, Blake accused Sturgeon of being a sexual predator. Sturgeon stated, “Blake will destroy people’s lives for no reason.” “And I don’t believe that’s all she’s capable of lying about.”
Sturgeon ”But if somebody has a differing opinion from Kimberly Blake, it doesn’t matter what it’s about, you might go back and forth with people, but then you end up getting blocked. And it’s like, well, what are you going to do if you’re mayor? You can’t block everybody under the sun.”
Sturgeon “The thing is, other people are scared to come forward. So she will ruin their lives further. I cannot even begin to tell you the number of people that she’s just tried to completely destroy their lives for no reason. And I’m willing to talk, because I’m like, what are you going to do to me? What more are you going to do to me?” Sturgeon claims that Blake has 4 or 5 online profiles. “I don’t know how any sane human being can have, like, four or five profiles and keep up with it. Of those fake profiles, if I remember the names, I would tell you. I don’t know.”
Sturgeon: “But Kimberly Blake is a narcissist. She knows how to get into people’s heads very easily. She’s very good at it.”
Sturgeon revealed that when Blake would receive donations for the homeless shelter, they would go to her partner’s cash app. Gardner Magazine could find no record of a non-profit being established for the purpose of collecting funds for the homeless shelter.
As far as Gardner Mayor Michael Nicholson receiving the honor of being elected to the Massachusetts Mayors Association, Sturgeon said “How can that possibly be a bad thing….Leave it to Paul and Kim and everybody that follows them to make it a bad thing. I’m like, how can you possibly spin that to be a bad thing…I have a screenshot somewhere of when that was announced and they spun it as a bad thing”